In machine learning, weighted majority algorithm wma is a meta learning algorithm used to construct a compound algorithm from a pool of prediction algorithms, which could be any type of learning algorithms, classifiers, or even real human experts. The banzhaf power index john banzhaf is an attorney and law professor. A weighted voting system will often be represented in a. In this paper we model the reliability of threshold weighted voting systems wvs with multifailuremodes, where a general recursive reliability function of the wvs is presented. Weighted voting the electoral college o ers a classic illustration of weighted voting. Problems with voting system standards university of iowa. Mathematics of voting and apportionment ernesto diaz. The stock exchange of hong kong the exchange has published a concept paper on weighted voting rights seeking views on whether companies with governance structures giving certain persons voting power or other. Math 017 lecture notes thus we can conclude making decisions in a consistently fair way is inherently impossible in a democratic society 2. The value of the electoral college see previous problem for an overview in modern. We also develop approximation formulas for calculating the reliability of wvs based on a large number of units. Thereto, we study various subclasses of simple games, and their associated representation methods.
Request pdf solving weighted voting game design problems optimally. If everybody but player 1 is a dummy, then player 1 must be a dictator. Finite math a chapter 2, weighted voting systems 1 one person one vote is an democratic idea of equality but what if the voters are not people but are governments. The electoral college offers a classic illustration of weighted voting.
Truefalse 2 points each answer the following questions about weighted voting systems by writing a t or f in the blank. All of the information about a weighted voting system can be captured. An example of how a paper based voting system is flawed and prone to corruption can be found in the haitian elections, where the last election was invalidated due to fraudulent paper ballots produced in dubai used to stuff the ballot boxes and elect a president illegally. Klosy yingqian zhangz abstract we study the inverse power index problem for weighted voting games. Weighted voting math 107 examples of weighted voting systems definitions players weights quota dictator veto power. Koether hampdensydney college fri, sep 15, 2017 robb t. Our goal is to find algorithms that solve this problem exactly. Complexity of problems for weighted voting games preliminary remarks complexity of problems for weighted voting games weighted voting games can be represented compactly, since only the weights of the n players and a quota need to be given. We study the inverse power index problem for weighted voting games. In weighted voting, we are most often interested in the power each voter has in. Abstract we study the inverse power index problem for weighted voting games.
A weighted voting system is characterized by three things the players, the weights and the quota. Ideas of voting power have been applied in a range of settings, including committee voting in legislatures, weighted voting as in corporations and hierarchical. Solving weighted voting game design problems optimally. Jones associate professor of computer science, university of iowa chair, iowa board of examiners for voting machines and electronic voting systems.
The video provided an introduction to weighted voting. Pdf an electronic voting system supporting vote weights. Weighted voting systems elissa brown chrissy donovan charles noneman june 5, 2009 voting systems can be deceptive. A weighted voting system wvs is a generalization of a koutofn system, and is widely used in many areas in cluding imprecise data handling 1, safety monitoring and self.
Weighted voting rights concept paper issued in hong kong. Short hand notation is discusses as well as the definitions of a dictactor, veto power, and dummy play. The value of the quota q is a 11 b 10 c d 12 e none of the above 5. Weighted voting is sometimes used to vote on candidates, but more commonly to decide yes or no on a proposal, sometimes called a motion.
Weighted voting is applicable in corporate settings, as well as decision. Any formal voting arrangement in which voters are not necessarily equal in. The complete list of power indexes 1, 2, n, is called the banzhaf power distribution of the weighted voting system. The sum of all the s is 1 or 100% if they are written as percentages. One of the most common examples of a weighted voting system is the u. Aug 24, 20 the video provided an introduction to weighted voting. Math 1001, weighted voting quiz, spring, 2003 remember, there will be little or no partial credit given on questions in this quiz. Hong kong weighted voting rights concept paper seeks views on whether listing of companies with dualclass shares in hong kong should be allowed. Pdf purpose this paper aims to provide a solution for allowing an. If the quota were exactly half or less than half, then many problems arise. Problems with voting systems and the applicable standards. In the following weighted voting systems, say which voters if any have veto power. Thus a generic weighted voting system with n players can be written as. The stock exchange of hong kong the exchange has published a concept paper on weighted voting rights seeking views on whether companies with governance.
Klosy yingqian zhangz abstract we study the power index voting game design problem for weighted voting games. Representations, synthesis, and enumeration we study the inverse power index problem for weighted voting games. Mathematics and social choice theory topic 1 voting systems. Hkex publishes concept paper on weighted voting rights. This implicitly tells us which of the altogether 2n possible coalitions of. Again, the agents might prefer an exante contract for payoff division to. Weighted majority algorithm machine learning wikipedia. Weighted majority voting game is characterized by a voting vector. The pages in this practice book can be assigned in order to provide practice with key. Voting problems npr examines voting problems for the 2008 election with a look at voter intimidation, voter fraud, registration irregularities and other issues at the polls.
Pdf solving weighted voting game design problems optimally. The online content platform for edward elgar publishing. Statistical science the mathematics and statistics of voting. Koether hampdensydney college weighted voting fri, sep 15, 2017 1 20. In 1965, his analysis of the power in the nassau county ny board of supervisors was used in a lawsuit, which resulted in a change in the system see page 55 for more details. The electoral college consists of 51 voters the 50 states plus dc each with a weight determined by the congressional delegation number of representative and senators. Weighted voting is applicable in corporate settings, as well as decision making in parliamentary governments and voting in the united nations security council. House of representatives committee on science washington d. Recall that a dictator is a member that is part of every winning coalition and is not a member of any losing ones. Reliability weighted voting games 39 the number of seats to vote for a new legislation, but may fail to do so with a certain probability. Modeling the reliability of threshold weighted voting systems.
530 320 1466 1279 559 759 168 1313 571 906 249 171 1307 1320 972 1547 1355 1337 1313 915 1386 543 1252 936 1421 1170 852 668 1003 830 1231 1482 1142 1460 693 266 831 1436 829 1452 1352 1217 615 1315 682